Stupid Dream-PORCUPINE TREE-1999

Perhaps Stupid Dream is one of the most melancholy and somber albums that PT has ever made till date. Yes, the mood that this band conjures up is always so, but on this even it is even more so. Maybe that is why this one has always ranked a little lower on my scale than the other PT albums (leaving the Incident aside of course).

On the other hand there are some songs on here that you would do well not to miss. The opener, Even Less, is one of my all time PT favorites, and is the best song on here. One for the greatest hits collection playah!! I rather not describe the song, in fact, I do not think that I can describe it. The second song to note on here is the poppish, catchy “Piano Lesson”. Check the lyrics-: “I remember piano lessons/The hours in freezing rooms/Cruel ears and tiny hands/Destroying timeless tunes/She said there’s too much out there/Too much already said/ You’d better give up hoping/You’re better off in bed” . Most of the times Steven Wilson’s lyrics are incredibly vague, though picturesque, but sometimes he just hits the button. Like on this one and “The Sound of Muzak” from In Absentia. Great stuff.

To tell the truth, the rest of the album passes in a sort of a haze. Maybe because the best cut is the opener, but the rest of the stuff is a bit iffy (for PT anyways). This might also be because of a lack of variation in song structure and style, but I can hardly remember what happens after “Don’t Hate Me”, which song has btw, some great sax going for it, also a rare occurrence. However, no real complaint again, since that is almost half the album! The album again is PT finding their sound and heading for what they must not have known, but we know, as In Absentia. Damn, how many times am I gonna mention that one in these PT reviews. As I shall note, the albums before this, namely Signify, The Sky Moves Sideways and Down the Upstair were high on experimentation, while from Stupid Dream onwards, till Fear of a Blank Planet, PT discovered the unique PT sound. Does that make sense? Whatever. And as for The Incident, the less spoken about it the better.

As for Stupid Dream, it is one the album that even a casual fan must hear to complete the PT experience. If not that, you are at the very least obliged to hear “Even Less”, which must be one of the all time great songs, in my book at least.

Recommended Songs-Even Less, Piano Lessons, Don’t Hate Me.

Baba T

5 thoughts on “Stupid Dream-PORCUPINE TREE-1999

  1. I completely concur with Baba. Even Less is an absolute classic. For all those reading this, “even less” is absolute genius, and what a guitar line in chorus!

    -El Bajista

  2. I don’t agree with most of this review apart from the brilliance of even less. Stupid dream is one of the best PT albums out their IMO with some mind-blowing guitar work. Why do we always have to compare an album with In Absentia or other later albums, can’t we just look at it in isolation. Again a concept album to be heard in its entirety to appreciate as wilson himself repeatedly says. Apart from the tracks mentioned i also like ‘Stranger by the minute(cool solo)’ and ‘A smart kid(outro solo is awesomeness)’. This infact is the only PT album(FAOBP also) in which i like all the tracks and can just enqueue the whole album & go on a journey with wilson. Though i love the metal side of PT more being a Metal head but still Stupid Dream impresses me due to the guitar work. This album is one of the finest works of steven wilson.Underrated album.

    • personal preference my dear friend…….that’s all…..i thnk we will agree to disagree…hehe

      Baba T

  3. Hmm i understand mate & respect ur preference..bottom line is PT Rules and with the kind of diverse fan base they have its hard to nail one Album as the best or another as not good. Anyways keep the reviews coming would love to discover more kick ass bands.

    PS: I would love it if you could review any of Mastodon’s albums..especially Blood Mountain or Crack the Skye

    • Hey sid.

      yeah PT totally rules, and yeah it may not always be on to compare every album to fear of… and in absentia. however, one can’t deny that with albums as landmark as those, SOME comparison is inevitable. for instance, Sgt Pepper is considered the yardstick which the beatles were to develop into prior to its release and what they became after it.

      anyway, its all opinions and i do get your point that everything cannot be compared to fear or in absentia.

      also, as far as the mastodon albums are concerned, we will get on them right away.


      el bajista

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s